
It’s pretty remarkable looking at the resiliency of the Toy Story franchise. The original 1995 film began the digital revolution of filmmaking, upending years of tradition in animation and forcing a sea change in the kinds of animated movies that would be made for decades to come. Within a decade of it’s premiere, all hand drawn movies would disappear from the multiplexes, including the ones from industry leader Disney, and all animated movies would be almost entirely computer generated. Pixar Animation, the Bay Area studio behind the creation of Toy Story, quickly became the new standard bearer of quality animation, and knowing just how valuable their name in the industry was, Disney decided to acquire them rather than see them grow into a competitor. Even under the wings of Disney, Pixar still managed to flourish over the next thirty years. With each new film they pushed their artform further, refining computer animation to the point where the lines between realism and hyper-realism become very blurred. And even with all the advancements they’ve made over the years, Pixar still manages to find time to revisit their roots with Toy Story. Rather than stay a relic of the past when computer animation was in it’s early rough stage, Toy Story has managed to remain relevant and popular with audiences. It’s a tribute to the timelessness of the original that it makes you forget about the rougher edges of that early 90’s computer animation. Apart from the innovative animation, Pixar has always prided themselves in putting characters and story at the forefront of what they do. They don’t move forward with a movie unless they believe that it’s a story worth telling, and they will often put years into refining those stories until they meet the high standards they set for themselves. While Pixar has brought us dozens of brilliant and wonderfully original stories, it is surprising how many different new ways they are able to expand the story of their original groundbreaking movie. Even after 30 years, we still haven’t seen the last of Toy Story.
It didn’t take long for the studio to devise a sequel. It fact, Toy Story 2 (1999), was only their third feature ever after the original and A Bug’s Life (1998). And what was more surprising was the fact that they managed to surpass the original in every way. While the first Toy Story was iconic in a lot of ways, 2 delved even deeper into the characters of Woody and Buzz Lightyear, and even raised the stakes, showing us what can happen when toys are no longer played with. For a long time, Toy Story 2 was considered the Empire Strikes Back of animation, because of how well it built on something that was already iconic, and made it even better. But, after a 10 year run of classic original films, the team at Pixar decided it was worth revisiting Toy Story again. Toy Story 3 (2010) somehow managed to build upon it’s already beloved predecessors and become an even bigger hit. It became only the third animated film to earn a Best Picture nomination at the Oscars and for many, it had what is considered the best ending of any Pixar film, with the toys saying their final goodbyes to the boy who once played with them before he heads off to college and adulthood. For a lot of people, they thought that this was the perfect way to bring the story of Toy Story to an end, but that’s not how the filmmakers at Pixar felt. In particular, Pixar legend Andrew Stanton, who was one of the writer on the first two Toy Story’s as well as the director of classics like Finding Nemo (2003) and Wall-E (2008), felt there was more to story to tell, especially for the character of Woody. He developed a new epilogue storyline for Woody which involves the old toy discovering a new direction for his life outside of being a child’s plaything, which also included him reconnecting with a lost love as well. Toy Story 4 (2019) was risky, picking the series up after another long gap in time and doing so after many felt the story had already completed on a perfect final note. But, again, Toy Story 4 defied expectations and won over audiences, becoming the highest grossing film in the series yet. Despite the odds, Toy Story has managed to deliver each time it comes back, showing resiliency that no other animated franchise has been able to match. But can Pixar manage to do it again with the release of yet another risky new chapter to this story with Toy Story 5?
Toy Story 5 takes place a short couple of years after the events of 4. The toys’ playful and creative little girl owner named Bonnie (Scarlett Spears) is now 8, and still hasn’t grown out of playtime. But, they also notice that Bonnie is also very shy and is struggling with making new friends. Jessie (Joan Cusack) becomes concerned and wonders why none of the other children in their neighborhood is playing with toys the same way that Bonnie is. She learns that all the children are not playing with toys, but rather are playing games on screen based tech gadgets. Jessie immediately becomes concerned about the encroachment of technology into the lives of children and that Bonnie might succumb to it too, but the other toys including Buzz Lightyear (Tim Allen) don’t share that same concern. However, Jessie’s fears are realized when Bonnie’s parents buy her a tech toy named Lilypad (Greta Lee). Lilypad wastes no time taking up all of Bonnie’s time, as she spends all day and night playing games on the toy tablet, while all the other toys are neglected. Jessie, who sees Lilypad as an existential threat, tries to prove that she is better at helping Bonnie connect with new friends, but a failed attempt to sneak her way into joining Bonnie on a sleep over causes Jessie to be lost and mistakenly picked up by strangers. Due to the address that’s been inked onto her boots for decades, Jessie ends up at the same rural home that was once owned by her original owner Emily; the same girl who abandoned her years ago. Jessie tries to find a way to get back to her new home, but she’s going to need the help of strangers in the form of some long neglected toys owned the new family that lives at the ranch house. One of them is an old school tech toy named Smarty Pants (Conan O’Brien), who challenges Jessie on her anti-tech bias. Meanwhile, Buzz Lightyear enlists the help his old buddy Woody (Tom Hanks) to help in finding out where Jessie has disappeared to, and that means finding ways to force the information out of Lilypad, who herself is also finding it difficult trying to get Bonnie to connect with other children. All the while, an army of Buzz Lightyear toys are making their way to civilization after their shipping crate washed up on a deserted island, with their only drive being their need to rendezvous with Star Command. With the toys scattered to the far winds again, will they all manage to find their way home, and more importantly, will they manage to get Bonnie to find happiness in friendship rather than wasting her time glued to a screen alone in her room.
Andrew Stanton, who has had a hand in scripting all 5 films in this series, takes the helm as director this time around in the series, which is a great benefit for this long running franchise. Under Stanton’s direction, he helps to keep that continuity from all the way back to the beginning in this franchise, which is very much needed in order to have this movie come anywhere near the high bar that’s been set. You would think that with four films already that Toy Story would be pretty much spent as a franchise, and for some, they believed that 4 was too many, given 3’s perfect ending. But, because this is Pixar, they wouldn’t have gone ahead with another film in their flagship franchise unless they had the right angle to explore, and thankfully they found it. The tech vs. toys angle is a brilliant way to not only bring new life into this long running franchise, but also make it timely as well. After 30 years, childrens’ attention spans have been altered by the introduction of gadgets like tablets and smart phones into their life, which may keep them occupied for a while, but it also disconnects them from the world as well. In the writing of this story, Stanton became concerned about the amount of time that young children are spending playing on these smart devices, and that it’s in a way robbing them of a childhood. Moreover, he’s also noticing that it’s causing a lot of children to ignore the other toys they have, which proved to be a great perspective to explore in this franchise all about toys and their want to be loved and played with by children. It is pretty remarkable that even after 30 years, the Toy Story franchise has yet to drop the ball and thankfully Toy Story 5 manages to live up to that high standard as well thanks to it’s smart and insightful take on how toys would react to the introduction of tech into their lives. Now, Stanton could have easily fallen into the trap of making an easy “toys good, tech bad” diatribe as part of the story, but thankfully Toy Story 5 is more nuanced than that. The presence of tech is not the problem. Obviously, the Pixar team would have come across as pretty hypocritical if they made that case, as their whole studio production line is run on computers. The case made in the movie is that the belief that tech is a solve all for all of our problems is the thing that is bad in our lives, and it’s even worse when children are involved.
Where the brilliance lies in this movie’s story is that they tells this story through the perspective of Jessie. Here, she is elevated to main character status, as it’s pretty clear that Buzz and Woody have already had their arcs fulfilled in past films. For Jessie, there is still some unprocessed trauma in her story, and the fight against tech gives her a perfect reason to finally confront some of that. No other character in the Toy Story franchise has had to deal with the tragedy of abandonment like her, which was also a main crux of her character development in Toy Story 2. So, to have her confront the existential threat of tech taking over a children’s playtime stirs up all of these old bad memories, and it thrusts Jessie’s story to the forefront in a way that we haven’t seen yet. What this also does is to help differentiate the movie from all the other Toy Story’s as the focus shifts to a different protagonist. And even though Jessie does get the lion’s share of development in this film, the movie doesn’t ignore the rest of the toys we’ve grown to love as well. Some even get more of a spotlight than we’ve ever seen before. The toy horse Bulls Eye also gets a lot more to do in this film than he has in the last three, and it’s great to see him actually be an active force in the story rather than just a funny animal sidekick. Buzz and Woody may take a back seat this time, but the movie still finds some fun ways to keep them engaged in the plot, including rekindling their rivalry in some ways again. If the movie has a bit of a flaw, it’s that the cast of characters seems a bit too overstuffed as most of them make a return here. Quite a few of the characters literally contribute nothing to the story and are just there to be seen so that longtime fans know they are still okay. But probably the best character development of all belongs to the girl Bonnie, as we see her struggle with growing up and not being able to fit in. Her growth as a character is at the heart of the story, and it becomes of the more emotional parts of the movie. At the same time, the movie still manages to balance the more emotional scenes with a lot of well earned humor as well. While it’s not the funniest movie in the series (I happen to think that Toy Story 4 had the best ratio of jokes that landed of all the films in the franchise), this movie will still leave you smiling with some really hilarious moments.
Of course this is a long standing franchise that has seen many great characters come and go over the years. It is particularly heartening to see longtime series fixtures like Tom Hanks and Tim Allen return every time to continue voicing their iconic characters. And it’s not just them, as other mainstays have also come back, such as Annie Potts as Bo Peep, Wallace Shawn as Rex and John Ratzenberger as Hamm have also returned, albeit in far more minor roles. They are all definitely welcomed back, but there’s no denying that the star of this film is Joan Cusack as Jessie. Here she gets the mainstage and she makes the most of it. She really comes into her own in this film, putting Jessie through an emotional roller coaster and brilliantly grounding her in some real emotional truth. This movie, in many ways, feel most like a companion piece to Toy Story 2 in the way that it delves deeper into the experience that helped to shape Jessie into who she is. She can definitely still play the boisterousness of Jessie in her most playful mode very well, but it’s the scenes where she has to get Jessie to some deeper reflection that Joan’s vocal performance really shines. And all the while, it still feels in line with all the other times she’s played this character over the last 27 years. Even though the movie seems a little overstuffed with characters that the series has collected over the years, it still manages to allow the new characters to leave a strong impression. The best of all of them is Conan O’Brien as the potty training toy Smarty Pants. He is a great addition to the cast, and Conan perfectly brings his already hilarious persona into the characterization of his character. A lot of credit should also go to the vocal performance of Greta Lee as Lilypad. It could have been too easy for Lee to play Lilypad as sterotypical villain for this story, but she managed to find several layers to the character that allows Lilypad to be a bit more complex than that. An antagonist for sure, but one who’s honestly motivated by the same goals as the heroes, which is to help Bonnie fit in with the other kids. Greta does a great job of helping to find that balance, making Lilypad adversarial but by no means malicious in her motivations. Overall, even though the cast seems a bit overwhelming, the film still finds enough time to let most of them shine, and that’s especially impressive given that some of these actors have been sticking aorund for over 30 year now.
I still maintain that Toy Story 4 is the most visually stunning of the Toy Story films, but 5 is no slouch either. Pixar would undercut their marquee franchise, so this sequel still meets the high standard that’s been set by the studio. It is interesting to see how computer animation has progressed over the years just by looking at the differences in detail between movies 1 and 5. Much of the original Toy Story is crude and flat in it’s background detail, given how their rendering resources were so limited at the time. Each subsequent movie since then has gotten better at not just animating the characters, but also making their worlds feel fleshed out. 5 continues that tradition of raising the bar, and it has some incredible visuals throughout. The subplot involving the army of Buzz Lightyears venturing through the wilderness offers up some of the best visuals in the movie, including a scene with a hilarious reference to Bambi (1942) of all things. The movie may not be as big of a visual breakthrough as some of Pixar’s other movies, like Inside Out (2015) or Coco (2017), but I don’t think that’s the intention either. It’s purpose is to feel in line with all the Toy Story’s that have come before it, and those movies have always been more story driven than anything else. But one thing that does still impress is the subtlety that they are able to bring into the character animation. While the original Toy Story team managed to do the best they could with character expressions given the limited software they had back then, today Pixar is able to run the gamut with no limits to the kinds of expressions they can give their characters. This is especially true with Jessie, who has to emote quite a bit in this film. And the animators did a great job capturing just the slightest little subtleties in the characters in the moments when they are meant to be introspective. The film also makes great use of the locations in the film. This is probably the Toy Story film with the most varied locations, and they all feel lived in with a lot of character all their own. Where I feel 4 still exceeds the rest is in the stunning use of color throughout the movie, and 5 keeps things a bit less saturatred and more grounded. It’s nevertheless a visually stunning film to look at and definitely on par with Pixar at their best.
I’ll have to reflect on the movie a bit longer to properly know where I would rank it in relation with the other Toy Story movies. The one thing that I know is that regardless of where it ranks, it still feels like a worthy successor to all the previous movies in the series. I still think Toy Story 2 is the best one, but this movie makes a strong case of knocking out 3 and 4 for the third and/or second place in the series. What I love best about it is that it found a way to be different from the rest. Making this a Jessie centered story was the right call, because Buzz and Woody really had no more angles to explore in their storylines, wheras there was still more to unravel with her. I love the fact that it ties back into that story of abandonment that shaped her as a character before, and it allows her to finally process that lingering trauma that she still had in the back of her mind. I also love the fact that Andrew Stanton and his team took a more nuanced approch towards tackling the issue of technology replacing toys. Tech is only as evil as the way it’s been used; or misused to be sepcific. The movie shows that tech can be fun and sometimes useful, but it’s not a substitute for actually human interaction. What’s troubling today is that too many kids are getting addicted to these screen based tech toys at too early a stage and it’s leading to social isolation, which just makes things worse for children overall. The movie’s main thesis is that moderation should be a guiding principle in life, especially when it comes to using this kind of technology. Too much screen time is bad for anyone, let alone kids, and Toy Story 5 wants us to be reminded of the fact that a fancy technology like tablets and smart phones should never be substitutes to living life in the real world. I feel like most audiences will be happy to see all their favorite characters returning the big screen again. Toy Story 5 may feel superfluous to some, but I think it shows that there still are worthwhile things worth exploring in this franchise, even after 5 films. It will be interesting to see if Pixar decides to go further beyond with a Toy Story 6. If it keeps going, it wouldn’t surprise me, but if this is the final chapter of the Toy Story series, I also think it does an adequate job of capping the series off, even though 3 has the best ending to be sure. It’s very reassuring that we still have a friend in these lovable toys, and that they are still capable of going to infinity and beyond.
Rating: 8.5/10



























































