
We are in an interesting time now with Super Hero movies. The genre flat out dominated the box office throughout the 2010’s, built on the backs of Christopher Nolan’s Dark Knight trilogy and the rise of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. It seemed for a while like movies based on comic books would be the golden goose that would never stop laying golden eggs, and it was true across the board. Not only was Marvel riding high, but so was their cross town rival DC, which saw massive hits with even their second tier heroes like Wonder Woman (2017), Aquaman (2018) and Shazam (2019). But after Covid and the continued rise of streaming, viewing habits began to shift, and these Super Hero movies were no longer gaining traction anymore at the box office. That’s not to say that comic book movies are a dying genre; big hitters like Batman, Spider-Man, and Deadpool have still been able to deliver billion dollar grosses for their respective studios. But it’s the lesser known characters that are underperforming at the box office, showing that there are limits to the coat tail riding that these franchises are capable of pulling off. While Marvel can still find success with their big franchise characters like Spider-Man, Thor, and Deadpool, they have a far more difficult time now getting us excited for something like say the Thunderbolts (2025) for instance, even despite that movie getting generally positive reviews. This is leading to a major re-evaluation of the genre as a whole. Marvel seems ready for a re-boot of sorts once they get past the next batch of Avengers movies. Meanwhile, DC has already started again from scratch with a whole new cinematic universe under the supervision of director James Gunn. The Gunniverse as some have dubbed it is still in it’s infancy, but like their counterparts at Marvel, DC is looking far ahead to what this cinematic universe could actually be. The hope from parent company Warner Brothers is that this re-boot will help ensure the health of the DC brand for the foreseeable future, but in a changing world where audience tastes are changing rapidly, this is not something that is guaranteed.
Thankfully, James Gunn and his DCU initiative couldn’t have asked for a better start. The choice was made to have the most iconic super hero of them all, Superman, lead the charge with a new film directed by Gunn himself. It was risky, given that Superman has had a hard time connecting with audiences over the years, with Superman Returns (2006) and Man of Steel (2013) being very polarizing films. But, James Gunn’s Superman (2025) managed to break that curse with a box office hit that was praised across the board by critics and audiences alike. Most of the praise was given to David Corenswet especially, with people proclaiming him to be the best Superman since the beloved Christopher Reeve. Gunn, who of course is no stranger to making comic book movies with broad appeal like he did at Marvel with the Guardians of the Galaxy (2014), showed that he could do the same thing at DC, and this made a lot of people hopeful that they indeed could stay competitive with Marvel and continue to keep the super hero genre alive. But that would also all depend on what comes after the big hits. James Gunn of course can’t direct every movie in the DC pipeline, so he has to delineate to other filmmakers in order to keep the slate of films coming. It’s an unusual situation where Gunn has to be what Kevin Feige is to Marvel, which the overseer of the entire enterprise, while at the same time being hands on with his own projects. The beginning of the DCU is very much frontloaded with Gunn’s own projects, which includes the Superman movies as well as his hit Peacemaker series on HBO. The test of the DCU will very much depend on the strength of the properties that Gunn has less involvement in. This summer we are getting the first film in the DCU from a different director, and it involves a character who has had a more difficult time connecting with audiences over the years than Superman has. The character of Kara Zor-El, aka Supergirl, has been a popular fixture in the comic books since her debut in 1959, but has yet to have that big breakout hit on the big screen. The last time she had her own movie, it was the disastrous 1984 film starring Helen Slater and Faye Dunaway. Can this 2026 reverse that trend, or is Supergirl just too unlucky at the box office.
Kara Zor-El (Milly Alcock) has lived a fairly lonely life as one of the last of her kind. She was born on the last remaining city of the planet Krypton called Argo, which itself began to die off when Kryptonite poisoning took hold of the population. Her father Zor-El (David Krumholtz) believed that the only way Kara would be safe is if she were sent to Earth to live with her cousin Kal-El as the only other survivor of Krypton. With her loyal dog Krypto by her side, Kara escaped Argo on a pod sent to Earth. Once there, she was greeted by Kal-El, now named Clark Kent (David Corenswet) who has become the hero known as Superman. On Earth, Kara has learned to fit in like her cousin, as well as master the new powers she has thanks to Krytonian ability to absorb energy from yellow suns. But, she still feels alone and isolated. So, she leaves Earth behind and heads out into the cosmos once again. She ends up visiting planets that orbit red stars because there her powers are lessened and she’s able to get drunk. During her bar hopping across the galaxy, she comes across a planet where the local population is being harassed by a group called the Brigands; a nasty gang or rogues known for pillaging innocent people across multiple planets and stealing their women and girls to perpetuate their all male race. The Brigands leader, Krem (Matthias Schoenaerts) attacked and killed an entire family belonging to a local weapons smith, except for the daughter named Ruthye (Eve Ridley). Ruthye runs into Kara at one of the seedy bars on the planet, and is astonished by her incredible bravery and strength, even with Kara’s powers in a reduced state near the red star. She tries to enlist Kara’s help to stop the Brigands and get her revenge on Krem, but Kara is not interested in getting involved. However, things change when the Brigands raid Kara’s own ship and more distressingly shot her dog Krypto with a Kryptonite laced dart. Kara has only three days to find the Brigands who carry the antidote and save Krypto from a painful death. This puts her in a reluctant alliance with Ruthye as their goals are now aligned. But, trouble still arises in their hunt as another party is also searching for the Brigands; a bounty hunter named Lobo (Jason Momoa). Can Kara save her dog in time while also guiding the young Ruthye down the right path?
The hope was that Supergirl would carry the momentum of Gunn’s Superman, and make audiences care about all the different characters that make up the DC canon. This particular film takes it’s inspiration from the 2021-22 comic book miniseries Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow, which follows the same basic premise of Kara helping a young alien girl avenge her family, which is a story that takes heavy inspiration from the Western novel True Grit by Charles Portis. It’s clear that the movie adaptation is also heavily inspired by James Gunn’s own Guardians of the Galaxy movies, with it’s interplanetary world-building and embrace of the weird and quirky. But, despite Gunn being a producer of this film, it is not a James Gunn movie. Instead, director Craig Gillespie (I, Tonya, Cruella, Lars and the Real Girl) takes the reins of this adaptation and that is probably where a lot of the problems with this film stand. Gillespie is a filmmaker that excels at smaller, character driven films. He seems to be lost a lot more when called upon to direct a big franchise project, and it really shows with Supergirl. This movie is sadly a mess from beginning to end. The plot is flimsy, the action set-pieces are non-sensical, and it’s horribly paced and edited as well. It’s clear that they wanted to create a movie in the same vein as Gunn’s Guardians trilogy, but it has none of the fun of those films. Truth be told, there are a lot worse super hero movies; this movie easily is better to sit through than Madame Web (2024). But, as a follow-up to a movie that worked on almost every level like Superman, this film is very much a big step backward. It’s honestly that feeling of disappointment while watching the film that hurts it the most, because the ingredients are there to make a great movie. I feel like it all comes down to Craig Gillespie being a bad match for the material. He could have delivered a better film if it played to his strengths as a filmmaker who is good at delving into his characters. We do get a little bit of that with the flashbacks to Kara’s childhood in the city of Argo, which is one of the film’s few highlights. Gillespie manages to successfully make us care about Kara as a character in those moments, but once we get back to the main plot, the character development gets buried under the weight of a lot of mindless action.
The movie’s saving grace is undoubtedly Kara herself. While the movie gets so much wrong with her story, there is no denying that Milly Alcock nails the character in her performance. She perfectly encapsulates Kara as a character, perfectly displaying the despair that is driving her self-destructive ways, while at the same time still showing her as a woman with agency. Milly manages to make Kara funny, but never to the point where she becomes a parody of herself. The biggest disappointment of this movie is that Milly’s performance is the only thing that works; it’s a performance in search of a better movie. She keeps you interested all the way through, and you want to see her succeed. And I do like the fact that they don’t put her into the Supergirl suit until the very end. It allows for Kara to stand out as an individual first and foremost and not have her be defined as a symbol. The best action movies are the ones that allow for their super heroes to be interesting characters both in and out of their costumes. While the movie as a whole doesn’t work very well, it at least allows for Kara to stand out as a more well rounded character. It’s all about her coming to accept herself as the hero everyone else sees her as. The whole point of her being on that bender at the start of this story is to show that she’s a lost soul in need of regaining her faith in herself. It’s one of the ingredients that is present in the story and could have become something special overall. But it unfortunately is undermined by the movie’s inability get anything else right. Milly Alcock still remains a great choice to play Kara, and hopefully she still remains a part of the DCU moving forward. But this movie does her no favors as it just feels lifeless in every other aspect. Her performance very much is like a small golden nugget buried under a giant mound of mud. It’s trying to shine through as best as it can, but you really need to dig through a lot of ugly to get to it.
It doesn’t help that a lot of the other performances in the film are fairly subpar. Eve Ridley seems like a nice kid who’s capable of giving a heartfelt performance. But her character Ruthye in this film is just the worst. She is a horribly one note character that never stops whining throughout the film about how she was wronged and that Kara is not living up to her potential. I chalk it up more to how the character is written than how Eve is performing her. Ruthye is an obnoxious character who constantly throws herself into harms way, which just ends up leading Kara to have to save her again and again constantly. She exists in this movie purely to move the plot forward and that’s it. And unfortunately, she is in nearly the entire film, right by Kara’s side. That’s probably why the Kara’s backstory scenes were the best parts of the movie, because it allowed us to actually focus on the only character we care about. But it’s not just Ruthye that drags the movie down. The film also unfortunately suffers from having a very weak villain as well. Matthias Schoenaerts’ Krem is as bland as they come; never once feeling as intimidating as the movie tries to make him be. He just is a brute that grunts and chuckles his way through the chaos he creates. It’s especially disappointing given just deep the rogues gallery of DC comics is that they couldn’t find a more interesting adversary for Kara to face. Krem has no connection to Kara or her story whatsoever; he’s just a nuisance that Kara could easily either destroy or just ignore completely. Krem obviously means more to Ruthye’s story, and the fact that they are both so one note as characters just illustrates the weakness of this plot overall. The only performance that comes anywhere close to standing out as well as Milly’s performance as Kara is Jason Momoa as Lobo. Lobo, the gritty monochromatic motorbike riding alien mercenary has been a fan favorite in the comic books for years, and it is nice to see him finally make his big screen debut. Momoa of course famously played the character of Aquaman for DC in the past, but it’s pretty clear that Lobo was a better fit for him as a performer because he more closely fit’s Momoa’s personality type, and James Gunn clearly agreed. Momoa is an ideal match for the character and he does make the most of his presence in this movie. It’s just unfortunate that Lobo doesn’t get much screentime. He comes and goes without much impact to the story, which again becomes a missed opportunity. It’s a shame that he had to make his debut this way. They are clearly setting Momoa’s Lobo up for bigger things in the future, including possibly a solo film. But if you want audiences to embrace the character, he should be given a better role to play from the start.
Another thing that works against the movie is the way it looks. This is a very ugly looking movie, with the majority of the film cast in garish shades of brown and green. It’s trying to go for that Guardians like aesthetic, where the outskirts of space has a vey lived in and grimy feel to it. But Guardians of the Galaxy was also a vibrant movie with lots of color, which helped to balance out the grime and rust of the different worlds it showcased. Every world in Supergirl just feels the same, and they all look dirty and unappealing. And none of the planets that the characters visit feel distinct. The only identifying aspects of the locations is that one planet is desert like while another has the feel of a prairie. None of the different locations feel unique or like anything you’ve ever seen before. Another aspect working against the movie is that the action scenes are poorly constructed. The fight choreography feels uninspired and it’s shot in a way where you have a hard time following what’s going on. The movie also is terribly edited. A lot of the action scenes just kind of peter out without a good button to bring them to an end. It just all feels like the movie’s storyline was put together through bullet points with no actual thought put into how each scene would flow together. I hate keep bringing up to how this compares to James Gunn’s own films, but Gunn is an expert in crafting action scenes that feel lively, inventive and unlike anything we’ve seen before. Take for instance the prison escape scene with Margot Robbie’s Harley Quinn in The Suicide Squad (2021), which was an extremely inventive and well choreographed scene. The Mr. Terrific beachfront fight scene from Superman was also a great example of James Gunn putting some extra creativity into his action scenes. I think that the reason we don’t see any of that here is because Craig Gillespie is not that kind of director, and he is out of his league when called upon to make a movie that is full of nothing but action set pieces. That’s why the film feels like it drags, despite being only a little over 100 minutes. I’ve seen comic book movies that run between 2 1/2 to 3 hours that fly by, so for this movie to feel so long despite being relatively short is a clear sign that something is fundamentally wrong with the film as a whole.
What worries me the most is that the failure of this movie is just going to send the wrong message to Hollywood. There is a contigent of the internet that has been very much rooting for this movie to fail, and their reason for wanting to see it fail is because of their own bigotted misogyny. They want to send the message to Hollywood that movies that center on female super heroes are destined to fail and that they should never be made in the first place, thereby ensuring that comic book movies remain a male centered genre. This is a horrible thing to believe, and my hope is that Hollywood ignores them. We shouldn’t be ignoring stories centered around female heroes; we just need to make them better. Supergirl deserves a much better movie than what she got here. She is a wonderful character that can easily hold her own. And I certainly wouldn’t trust the misogynistic haters online to determine what direction to take with the character either, because you know all they would do is just sexualize her and turn her into a one note character that fits within their idea of what a woman should be. The movie does deserve credit for at least trying to make Kara more than just a symbol of womanhood. She is a character that goes through struggles just like everyone else. The movie, for all it’s flaws, still got it’s main character right, and that’s not nothing. Milly Alcock deserves a lot of credit for making Kara a character worth rooting for and I do hope she manages to shine a bit brighter in James Gunn’s next Superman film, in which she’s going to play a substantial role in. But, what this movie shows is that there needs to be a better vision for everything else in the DCU. We can always count on James Gunn to deliver, but there needs to be better talent involved in the making of all the other upcoming films. The other directors in the DCU should not feel like they need to ape Gunn’s style, and instead find their own voice in telling these stories. Craig Gillespie was just not the right guy for this kind of movie. It’s been a tough road for Supergirl on the big screen, from the 1984 original to the unfortunately wasted potential of her appearing in 2023’s The Flash. This film is not the absolute worst it could have been, as they did get her right as a character, but it too also feels like a wasted opportunity that unfortunately will have a chilling effect on female based comic book movies and only empower the worst kinds of voices on the internet. Supergirl deserves better, and I hope we do get to see her given the cinematic treatment she deserves in the future.
Rating: 5.5/10



























































